How do you plan and write the 12-mark Section B extended comparison?
The Component 3 Section B extended-response question (12 marks): comparing and evaluating a set work with an unfamiliar piece across the musical elements, structuring a balanced, evaluative answer that reaches a conclusion.
A focused answer to the Edexcel GCSE Music Component 3 Section B extended-response question, covering how to compare and evaluate a set work with an unfamiliar piece across the musical elements, structure a balanced comparison, use the score, and reach an evaluative conclusion for the 12-mark question.
Reviewed by: AI editorial process; not yet individually human-reviewed
Have a quick question? Jump to the Q&A page
Jump to a section
What this dot point is asking
Section B is a single extended-response question worth 12 marks, the biggest question on the paper. It asks you to compare and evaluate a set work with an unfamiliar piece (related to one of the set works), referring to the scores and what you hear. It is marked by levels for both musical knowledge and the quality of comparison and evaluation, so structure and judgement matter as much as content.
What Section B asks
Plan before you write
Write comparative, not separate, paragraphs
Reach an evaluative conclusion
How Edexcel examines this
Section B is marked using levels of response, assessing both knowledge and understanding and the quality of evaluation and conclusion. The mark scheme rewards sustained, balanced comparison, accurate element vocabulary, use of the scores, and a justified judgement. It penalises two separate descriptions and answers that list without evaluating. Practise by comparing each set work with a wider-listening piece, planning with the element grid and writing a judged conclusion, against the timing.
Try this
Q1. How many marks is Section B worth, and what does it ask you to do? [Knowledge recall]
- Cue. 12 marks; compare and evaluate a set work with a related unfamiliar piece across the musical elements.
Q2. What turns a comparison into a top-band Section B answer? [Short explanation]
- Cue. An evaluative conclusion, a justified judgement of which piece uses the elements more effectively and why, alongside balanced, sustained comparison.
Exam-style practice questions
Practice questions written in the style of Pearson Edexcel exam questions on this dot point, with worked answer explainers. The year tag is the paper they imitate, not the source.
Edexcel 202012 marksCompare and evaluate the musical elements of one set work with the unfamiliar piece provided. You should refer to the scores and what you have heard. (Component 3, Section B extended response)Show worked answer →
Twelve marks, marked by levels for knowledge and understanding and for the quality of comparison and evaluation. A top-band answer compares both extracts element by element (melody, instrumentation, texture, tonality, harmony, rhythm, dynamics, structure), putting both pieces in the same point with comparative language, uses precise vocabulary and the scores (bar references), and reaches a clear evaluative conclusion (which uses the elements more effectively, and why). Markers reward sustained, balanced comparison and a justified judgement, not two separate descriptions or a list without evaluation.
Edexcel 202212 marksEvaluate how the set work and the unfamiliar piece each use musical elements to create their effect or mood, comparing the two. (Component 3, Section B extended response)Show worked answer →
Twelve marks by levels. Plan with the elements, then write comparative paragraphs that judge how each piece achieves its effect: for example, how each creates drama, mood or energy through tonality, dynamics, texture and instrumentation, drawing genuine similarities and differences and supporting points from the scores. Conclude with an evaluative judgement about which is more effective and why. Markers reward the quality of evaluation and conclusion as well as accurate musical knowledge, so the answer must judge, not just describe both pieces.
Related dot points
- The structure of the Component 3 Appraising exam (Section A and Section B, 80 marks), the question types (multiple choice, grid, short and free response, dictation and extended comparison) and how to manage the playing of audio extracts.
A focused answer to the structure and technique of the Edexcel GCSE Music Component 3 Appraising exam, covering Section A and Section B, the 80-mark layout, the multiple-choice, grid, short-answer, dictation and extended-comparison question types, and how to use the repeated audio extracts effectively.
- The Component 3 unfamiliar-piece question (8 marks): applying set-work knowledge to a related unfamiliar extract, using the skeleton score and the musical elements to comment on its features.
A focused answer to the Edexcel GCSE Music Component 3 unfamiliar-piece question, covering how to apply set-work knowledge to a related unfamiliar extract, use the skeleton score with bar references, work through the musical elements, and link features back to the related set work for the 8-mark question.
- The Component 3 dictation question (worth 6 to 10 marks): completing missing notes, rhythms or chords on a score by ear, using pulse, intervals, note values and the conventions of the set works.
A focused answer to the Edexcel GCSE Music Component 3 dictation question, covering how to complete missing notes, rhythms and chords by ear, counting the pulse and beats per bar, working out intervals and note values, and the dictation method the appraising exam rewards.
- The musical elements examined in Component 3, organised by the MAD T-SHIRP framework (melody, articulation, dynamics, texture, structure, harmony, instrumentation, rhythm and pitch), and how to use them with precise vocabulary.
A focused answer to the Edexcel GCSE Music musical elements, covering the MAD T-SHIRP framework (melody, articulation, dynamics, texture, structure, harmony, instrumentation, rhythm and pitch) and how to use each element with accurate vocabulary to score in the Component 3 appraising exam.
- Comparing the two instrumental set works (Bach's Brandenburg finale and Beethoven's Pathetique) across the musical elements, and applying that comparison to the 12-mark Section B extended response.
A focused answer comparing the two Edexcel GCSE Music instrumental set works, Bach's Brandenburg Concerto No. 5 finale and Beethoven's Pathetique Sonata, across the musical elements (Baroque versus Classical style, ensemble versus solo, counterpoint versus drama), and how to structure the 12-mark Section B comparison.
Sources & how we know this
- Pearson Edexcel GCSE (9-1) Music (1MU0) specification — Pearson (2016)