Why can a profitable business still run out of money?
The importance of cash to a business (to pay suppliers, overheads and employees, and to prevent insolvency), the difference between cash and profit, and the calculation and interpretation of cash-flow forecasts (cash inflows, cash outflows, net cash flow, opening and closing balances).
A focused answer to Edexcel GCSE Business 1.3.3, covering why cash matters, the difference between cash and profit, and how to calculate and interpret a cash-flow forecast (inflows, outflows, net cash flow, opening and closing balances).
Reviewed by: AI editorial process; not yet individually human-reviewed
Have a quick question? Jump to the Q&A page
Jump to a section
What this dot point is asking
Edexcel wants you to explain why cash is vital to a business, how cash differs from profit, and how to construct and interpret a cash-flow forecast, including net cash flow and the opening and closing balances.
Why cash matters
Cash is what keeps the doors open day to day. A business that cannot pay its bills, wages and suppliers when they are due is insolvent, and insolvency, not a lack of profit, is the most common immediate cause of small-business failure. This is why Edexcel treats managing cash as a survival issue, especially for start-ups and seasonal businesses whose income is uneven.
Cash versus profit
The difference is timing. Profit is recorded when a sale is made, even if the customer pays 60 days later; cash only counts the money when it actually arrives. So a manufacturer can win a large, profitable order but pay for the materials and labour weeks before the customer settles the invoice. In that gap it needs cash to keep trading. Three things commonly cause a profitable business to run short of cash:
- giving customers credit, so sales are made but the cash arrives late,
- overtrading, where a fast-growing business buys ever more stock before the cash from earlier sales has come in,
- tying cash up in stock or equipment, money now sitting on shelves or in machinery rather than the bank.
A worked feel for the gap: a firm sells goods for in March that cost to make. The profit is . But if it paid the to suppliers in March and the customer pays in May, the firm is down in March and April even though the deal is profitable. That two-month cash gap is what a forecast exposes.
The cash-flow forecast
Reading a forecast is about spotting the lowest closing balance and acting before it turns negative. A forecast is only an estimate, so its weakness is that real inflows can be lower and outflows higher than predicted; sensible businesses build in a buffer. If a forecast shows a negative closing balance ahead, the business can arrange an overdraft, chase customers to pay sooner, delay payments to suppliers, or cut costs before the shortage hits.
Try this
Q1. A month has inflows of and outflows of . State the net cash flow. [1 mark]
- Cue. .
Q2. Explain one action a business could take if its forecast shows a negative closing balance next month. [3 marks]
- Cue. Arrange an overdraft, chase customers to pay sooner, delay supplier payments, or cut costs, with a brief reason.
Exam-style practice questions
Practice questions written in the style of Pearson Edexcel exam questions on this dot point, with worked answer explainers. The year tag is the paper they imitate, not the source.
Edexcel 20194 marksIn March a business has an opening balance of , cash inflows of and cash outflows of . Calculate the net cash flow and the closing balance for March. (Paper 1, Section A)Show worked answer β
Two calculations, two marks each, method rewarded.
Net cash flow inflows outflows (a negative figure, shown with the minus sign).
Closing balance opening balance net cash flow .
Full marks need both the negative net cash flow and the negative closing balance, correctly carried through. A common error is to report the closing balance as just the net cash flow (), forgetting to add the opening balance. A negative closing balance signals the business needs an overdraft or other action before April.
Edexcel 20219 marksA profitable furniture maker has been refused further bank credit and is struggling to pay its suppliers on time. Justify one method the business could use to improve its cash-flow position. (Paper 1, Section C)Show worked answer β
A 9-mark justify question (Section C, evaluation) needs a clear recommendation, a developed chain applied to the firm, and a judgement against an alternative.
A strong answer might recommend negotiating longer trade credit with suppliers (paying after 60 rather than 30 days). This keeps cash in the business longer so it can meet wages and overheads now, easing the immediate shortage without taking on costly new debt, which suits a firm the bank has just refused. Application: a furniture maker buys high-value timber, so the cash held back is significant.
Justify by weighing it against chasing customers for faster payment: that brings cash in sooner but risks annoying customers and may be too slow. The recommended option is better here because it acts immediately and the bank route is closed. Markers reward a supported judgement, not two options listed without a decision.
Related dot points
- The concept and calculation of revenue, fixed and variable costs, total costs, profit and loss, interest, the break-even level of output and the margin of safety; and the interpretation of break-even diagrams, including the impact of changes in revenue and costs.
A focused answer to Edexcel GCSE Business 1.3.2, covering the calculation of revenue, fixed and variable costs, total costs, profit, interest, the break-even level of output and the margin of safety, and interpreting break-even diagrams.
- Sources of finance for a start-up or established small business: short-term sources (overdraft and trade credit) and long-term sources (personal savings, venture capital, share capital, loans, retained profit and crowd funding), and their suitability.
A focused answer to Edexcel GCSE Business 1.3.4, covering short-term sources of finance (overdraft, trade credit) and long-term sources (personal savings, venture capital, share capital, loans, retained profit, crowd funding) for a start-up or small business.
- What business aims and objectives are; financial aims and objectives (survival, profit, sales, market share, financial security) and non-financial aims and objectives (social objectives, personal satisfaction, challenge, independence and control) when starting up; and why aims and objectives differ between businesses.
A focused answer to Edexcel GCSE Business 1.3.1, covering what business aims and objectives are, financial aims (survival, profit, sales, market share, security) and non-financial aims (social, personal satisfaction, challenge, independence), and why they differ between businesses.
- The concept and calculation of gross profit and net profit; the calculation and interpretation of the gross profit margin, the net profit margin, and the average rate of return.
A focused answer to Edexcel GCSE Business 2.4.1, covering the calculation of gross profit and net profit, the gross and net profit margins, and the average rate of return, with worked examples.
- Managing stock (interpreting bar gate stock graphs and using just-in-time stock control); the role of procurement (relationships with suppliers based on quality, delivery, availability, cost and trust); and the impact of logistics and supply decisions on costs, reputation and customer satisfaction.
A focused answer to Edexcel GCSE Business 2.3.2, covering stock management (bar gate stock graphs and just-in-time), the role of procurement and supplier relationships, and the impact of logistics and supply decisions on costs, reputation and customer satisfaction.
Sources & how we know this
- Pearson Edexcel GCSE (9-1) Business (1BS0) specification β Pearson Edexcel (2017)