How do humans change the characteristics of organisms by selective breeding and by genetic engineering?
Selective breeding (artificial selection) and its uses and risks, the process and uses of genetic engineering including genetically modified crops and bacteria producing insulin, the benefits, risks and ethics of genetic modification, and an outline of tissue culture and cloning.
A focused answer to the OCR Gateway GCSE Biology A topic B5 on selective breeding and genetic engineering, covering artificial selection and its risks, the process and uses of genetic engineering including GM crops and bacteria producing insulin, the benefits, risks and ethics of genetic modification, and an outline of cloning.
Reviewed by: AI editorial process; not yet individually human-reviewed
Have a quick question? Jump to the Q&A page
Jump to a section
What this dot point is asking
OCR wants you to describe selective breeding (artificial selection) and its risks, describe the process and uses of genetic engineering including GM crops and bacteria making insulin, evaluate the benefits, risks and ethics of genetic modification, and outline cloning.
Selective breeding (artificial selection)
The process is the same whatever the organism:
- From a population, select the individuals with the desired characteristic.
- Breed these individuals together.
- From the offspring, again select those with the best form of the characteristic and breed them.
- Repeat over many generations until the characteristic is strongly expressed.
Useful characteristics chosen include higher crop yields, disease resistance in crops, more milk or meat from animals, gentle temperament in pets, and large or unusual flowers.
Genetic engineering
A classic example is engineering bacteria to make human insulin for people with diabetes:
- The gene for human insulin is cut out of human DNA using enzymes.
- The same enzymes cut open a small ring of bacterial DNA called a plasmid.
- The insulin gene is inserted into the plasmid, which acts as a vector (a carrier).
- The plasmid is put back into a bacterium, which then reproduces and makes human insulin, which is collected and purified.
This produces large amounts of insulin quickly and cheaply, identical to human insulin and without using animals.
Uses, benefits and risks of GM
Genetic engineering has many uses you can quote:
- GM crops engineered for higher yields, resistance to pests, herbicides or disease, or added nutrients (for example "golden rice" with extra beta-carotene to reduce vitamin A deficiency).
- Bacteria engineered to make medicines such as insulin and other proteins.
The benefits include more food, less use of pesticides, and cheaper medicines. The risks and ethical concerns that OCR expects you to discuss include:
- Possible effects on human health that are not yet fully known.
- Effects on the environment, for example GM genes spreading to wild plants, or harming insects such as pollinators, and reducing biodiversity.
- Ethical and economic worries, for example farmers depending on companies that own the GM seeds.
OCR rewards a balanced answer that weighs benefits against risks rather than only one side.
Cloning
A clone is a genetically identical copy of an organism. In plants, tissue culture grows many identical plants from a few cells of a parent plant, which is useful for mass-producing a plant with desirable characteristics or for preserving rare species. In animals, cloning can copy an animal with useful characteristics. Because clones are genetically identical, cloning, like selective breeding, produces no genetic variation.
Exam-style practice questions
Practice questions written in the style of OCR exam questions on this dot point, with worked answer explainers. The year tag is the paper they imitate, not the source.
OCR 20184 marksDescribe the steps a farmer would take to selectively breed dairy cattle that produce more milk, and explain one risk of selective breeding to the herd.Show worked answer →
A B5 structured question on artificial selection.
Steps: from the herd, choose (select) the cattle with the desired characteristic, here the cows that produce the most milk, and breed them together. From their offspring, again select those that produce the most milk and breed them. Repeat this over many generations, each time breeding from the best, so the characteristic becomes more and more pronounced.
Risk: selective breeding reduces the genetic variation in the herd (inbreeding), because the same desirable alleles are repeatedly bred together. This can increase the chance of inherited diseases or defects, and means the herd is less able to cope with a new disease or change in conditions. Reward the select, breed, select again over generations sequence, and a valid risk (reduced variation/inbreeding and its consequence).
OCR 20214 marksBacteria can be genetically engineered to produce human insulin. Describe how a gene is transferred into the bacteria, and give one advantage of producing insulin this way.Show worked answer →
A B5 question on genetic engineering.
How the gene is transferred: the gene for human insulin is cut out of human DNA using enzymes. The same enzymes are used to cut open a small ring of bacterial DNA called a plasmid. The insulin gene is inserted into the plasmid, and the plasmid (the vector) is put back into a bacterium. The bacterium then reproduces, and as it does so it makes human insulin, which is collected and purified.
Advantage: large amounts of human insulin can be made quickly and cheaply, it is identical to human insulin (so less likely to cause a reaction than insulin extracted from animals), and it avoids using animals. Reward the use of enzymes to cut the gene and the plasmid, inserting the gene into the plasmid/vector and into the bacterium, and a valid advantage.
Related dot points
- Variation and natural selection, Darwin's theory of evolution by natural selection, the development of antibiotic-resistant bacteria, the evidence for evolution from fossils and from resistant bacteria, extinction, and the formation of new species by isolation.
A focused answer to the OCR Gateway GCSE Biology A topic B5 on natural selection and evolution, covering variation and selection, Darwin's theory of evolution by natural selection, antibiotic-resistant bacteria, the evidence from fossils, extinction, and the formation of new species by isolation.
- Alleles, dominant and recessive, genotype and phenotype, homozygous and heterozygous, monohybrid crosses and Punnett squares, the inheritance of sex by the X and Y chromosomes, and single-gene inherited disorders such as cystic fibrosis and polydactyly.
A focused answer to the OCR Gateway GCSE Biology A topic B5 on genetic inheritance, covering alleles, dominant and recessive, genotype and phenotype, homozygous and heterozygous, monohybrid crosses with Punnett squares, the inheritance of sex, and single-gene inherited disorders such as cystic fibrosis and polydactyly.
- The structure of DNA as a double helix of nucleotides with complementary base pairing, the genome as the entire genetic material of an organism, the value of sequencing the human genome, and the causes of genetic and environmental variation including mutation.
A focused answer to the OCR Gateway GCSE Biology A topic B5 on DNA, the genome and variation, covering the double helix and complementary base pairing, genes and chromosomes, the genome and the value of the Human Genome Project, and the genetic and environmental causes of variation including mutation.
- Food security and the factors that threaten it, methods used to increase food production including fertilisers, pest control and intensive farming, biological control, the use of genetically modified crops, and sustainable approaches to feeding a growing human population.
A focused answer to the OCR Gateway GCSE Biology A topic B6 on feeding the human race, covering food security and its threats, methods to increase food production including fertilisers, pest control and intensive farming, biological control, the use of genetically modified crops, and sustainable approaches to feeding a growing population.
- The control of blood glucose concentration by insulin and glucagon, the roles of the pancreas and liver, negative feedback, and the causes and treatment of type 1 and type 2 diabetes.
A focused answer to the OCR Gateway GCSE Biology A topic B3 on the control of blood glucose, covering insulin and glucagon, the pancreas and liver, negative feedback, and the causes and treatment of type 1 and type 2 diabetes.