Why did Henry VIII break with Rome, and how far did it transform the English Church and state between 1509 and 1547?
Unit 1 Option (e.g. Y106 England 1485 to 1558): Henry VIII and Wolsey, the divorce campaign and the break with Rome, the royal supremacy and the Reformation, the dissolution of the monasteries and the Pilgrimage of Grace.
An OCR A-Level History Unit 1 British period study guide to Henry VIII and the break with Rome from 1509 to 1547. Covers Wolsey's ministry, the divorce and the King's Great Matter, the royal supremacy and the Reformation statutes, the dissolution of the monasteries, the Pilgrimage of Grace and the role of Cromwell, with the essay and enquiry skills Unit 1 rewards.
Reviewed by: AI editorial process; not yet individually human-reviewed
Have a quick question? Jump to the Q&A page
Jump to a section
What this dot point is asking
OCR Unit 1 for the Early Tudors covers Henry VIII (1509 to 1547) and the central drama of the reign, the break with Rome. You need to explain Wolsey's ministry, the divorce (the King's Great Matter), the royal supremacy and the Reformation statutes, the dissolution of the monasteries, the Pilgrimage of Grace and the role of Thomas Cromwell. The Section B essay (AO1) asks you to judge causes and consequences across the reign.
The answer
Wolsey and the road to the divorce
The break with Rome
When the papal route failed, Henry, increasingly advised by Thomas Cromwell, broke with Rome through Parliament, a deliberate use of statute law to make the break permanent and national:
- The Act in Restraint of Appeals (1533) blocked appeals to Rome, declaring that England was an "empire" with no superior, and allowed Cranmer to annul the marriage and validate that to Anne Boleyn.
- The Act of Supremacy (1534) declared the king Supreme Head of the Church of England.
- The Treasons Act (1534) made it treason to deny the supremacy, leading to the executions of Sir Thomas More and Bishop Fisher (1535).
The dissolution and the Pilgrimage of Grace
The religious changes provoked the Pilgrimage of Grace (1536), a massive rising in the north led by Robert Aske, demanding the restoration of the monasteries and the removal of Cromwell. Henry crushed it by promising concessions and then breaking his word, executing the leaders, the most dangerous rebellion any Tudor faced.
How far did it transform Church and state?
By 1547 England had a national Church under royal control and the Crown was vastly enriched, while the power of Parliament had grown through its use to enact the Reformation. Yet doctrine remained largely Catholic: the Act of Six Articles (1539) reaffirmed traditional beliefs. The transformation was therefore more institutional and political than doctrinal, a point strong essays draw out.
Examples in context
A model paragraph on consequences would argue that the Reformation transformed the state more than the faith: the supremacy and the dissolution hugely increased royal power and wealth, but the Six Articles of 1539 show doctrine stayed conservative, so England in 1547 was Catholic in belief but no longer Roman in obedience.
Try this
Q1. To what extent was Thomas Cromwell responsible for the changes in Church and state in the years 1534 to 1540? [20 marks]
- What the marker wants. An AO1 essay weighing Cromwell's role (the statutory supremacy, the dissolution, administrative reform) against the king's will, wider forces and the limits of doctrinal change, with a judgement on his responsibility.
Q2. What did the Act of Supremacy establish in 1534? [2 marks]
- Cue. It declared Henry VIII Supreme Head of the Church of England, formally breaking the English Church from the authority of the Pope.
Exam-style practice questions
Practice questions written in the style of OCR exam questions on this dot point, with worked answer explainers. The year tag is the paper they imitate, not the source.
OCR H505 Y106 201820 marksTo what extent was the desire for a divorce the main reason for Henry VIII's break with Rome in the years 1527 to 1534?Show worked answer →
A Section B period study essay (AO1), ranking the causes of the break and judging. Level 6 weighs the divorce against other drivers rather than narrating events.
For. The break followed directly from the King's Great Matter: the need to annul the marriage to Catherine of Aragon to secure a male heir, blocked by the Pope (who was under the influence of Catherine's nephew, Charles V), drove the Act of Supremacy in 1534.
Against. Anti-clericalism, Henry's hunger for Church wealth and power, the influence of Anne Boleyn and reformers, and the political skill of Thomas Cromwell in framing the supremacy through statute all mattered; some historians see a wider growth of royal authority.
Level 6 judges that the divorce was the trigger but that the form of the break (a permanent royal supremacy, not a temporary fix) owed much to Cromwell, ambition and circumstance.
OCR H505 Y106 202020 marksHow far do you agree that the dissolution of the monasteries was driven mainly by financial motives in the years 1536 to 1540?Show worked answer →
A Section B essay (AO1) on the motives for the dissolution, weighing finance against religion and politics.
For finance. The monasteries were vastly wealthy; their dissolution (the smaller houses from 1536, the larger from 1539) transferred land and treasure to the Crown and was managed by the Court of Augmentations, funding the regime.
Against. Reforming and anti-papal motives (monasteries as centres of loyalty to Rome), political consolidation of the supremacy, and Cromwell's wider programme also drove it; the Valor Ecclesiasticus survey of 1535 served both fiscal and reforming ends.
Level 6 judges that finance was central but inseparable from the assertion of royal supremacy, since dissolving the monasteries destroyed an institution loyal to the Pope as well as enriching the Crown.
Related dot points
- Unit 1 Option (e.g. Y106 England 1485 to 1558): the establishment of the Tudor dynasty under Henry VII, his government and finance, the pretenders and rebellions he faced, and his foreign policy and consolidation of power.
An OCR A-Level History Unit 1 British period study guide to the establishment of the Tudor dynasty under Henry VII from 1485 to 1509. Covers Bosworth and the securing of the throne, government and royal finance, the pretenders Simnel and Warbeck, the major rebellions, and foreign policy, with the period-essay and enquiry skills the paper rewards.
- Unit 1 Option (e.g. Y106 England 1485 to 1558): Edward VI and the Protestant Reformation, the protectorates of Somerset and Northumberland, the rebellions of 1549, the succession crisis of 1553, and Mary I's Catholic restoration, marriage and rebellion.
An OCR A-Level History Unit 1 British period study guide to the mid-Tudor crisis from 1547 to 1558. Covers Edward VI and the Protestant Reformation, the rule of Somerset and Northumberland, the rebellions of 1549, the disputed succession of 1553, and Mary I's Catholic restoration, Spanish marriage and Wyatt's rebellion, with the debate over whether there was a crisis.
- Unit 1 Section A: the enquiry question, evaluating four contemporary sources for their use in testing a given hypothesis, weighing content and provenance against the historical context (AO2).
An OCR A-Level History Unit 1 guide to the Section A enquiry. Explains how to answer the source question, evaluating four contemporary sources for their use in testing a hypothesis, weighing content and provenance against the historical context, with a Tudor worked example and the AO2 skills the enquiry rewards.
- Unit 1 Section B: the period study essay, building a sustained analytical argument across the period that ranks factors and reaches a substantiated judgement (AO1).
An OCR A-Level History Unit 1 guide to the Section B period study essay. Explains how to read the command, plan a ranked thematic argument across the period, deploy precise evidence and reach a substantiated judgement for AO1, with a worked Tudor example and the essay skills the paper rewards.
- Unit 3 Option (e.g. Y306 Rebellion and Disorder under the Tudors 1485 to 1603): the thematic study of the causes, course and significance of Tudor rebellions, the maintenance of order, and the changing relationship between the Crown and its subjects.
An OCR A-Level History Unit 3 thematic study guide to Rebellion and Disorder under the Tudors from 1485 to 1603. Covers the causes of rebellion (dynastic, religious, economic and political), the major risings, the Crown's methods of maintaining order, and the changing relationship between government and subjects, with the synoptic essay skills the paper rewards.
Sources & how we know this
- OCR A Level History A (H505) specification — OCR (2015)