How does an op-amp without feedback compare two voltages, and how does positive feedback give clean, noise-immune switching?
Comparators and Schmitt triggers: the open-loop comparator, the difference between a comparator and an amplifier, positive feedback, hysteresis, and switching thresholds.
An Eduqas A-Level Electronics answer on comparators and Schmitt triggers: the op-amp used open-loop as a comparator, why it differs from an amplifier, how positive feedback creates a Schmitt trigger with two switching thresholds, and how the resulting hysteresis gives clean switching in the presence of noise.
Reviewed by: AI editorial process; not yet individually human-reviewed
Have a quick question? Jump to the Q&A page
Jump to a section
What this dot point is asking
Eduqas wants you to use an op-amp open-loop as a comparator, distinguish a comparator from an amplifier, and explain how positive feedback creates a Schmitt trigger with two switching thresholds (hysteresis) for clean, noise-immune switching. This is the bridge between the analogue and digital worlds.
The answer
The comparator
Comparator versus amplifier
Positive feedback and the Schmitt trigger
Hysteresis and noise immunity
Examples in context
Comparators and Schmitt triggers are the analogue-to-digital interface of a system: a comparator turns a light-sensor or temperature-sensor voltage into an on or off decision (a dark detector, a thermostat), and a Schmitt trigger cleans a noisy or slow signal into a crisp logic edge before it reaches a counter, a microcontroller input, or a 555 timer. The same positive-feedback idea underlies the 555 timer and oscillators.
Try this
Q1. State what an op-amp comparator does. [2 marks]
- Cue. It compares its two input voltages and drives its output fully high or low depending on which is larger.
Q2. State the type of feedback used in a Schmitt trigger. [1 mark]
- Cue. Positive feedback (to the non-inverting input).
Q3. A Schmitt trigger has thresholds at and . State its hysteresis. [1 mark]
- Cue. .
Exam-style practice questions
Practice questions written in the style of WJEC Eduqas exam questions on this dot point, with worked answer explainers. The year tag is the paper they imitate, not the source.
Eduqas 20205 marksAn op-amp comparator has its inverting input connected to a reference and its non-inverting input connected to a sensor. The supply rails are and . Describe the output for a sensor voltage of and for , and explain why the output switches sharply.Show worked answer →
Outputs (up to 3 marks): with the sensor on the non-inverting input and the reference on the inverting input, the output goes high (near ) when the sensor exceeds the reference and low (near ) when it is below. At (below ) the output is low (); at (above ) the output is high ().
Sharp switching (up to 2 marks): the op-amp's open-loop gain is enormous, so even a tiny difference between the inputs drives the output fully to one rail or the other; there is no feedback to set an intermediate gain, so the output saturates and the transition is very steep.
Markers reward the low output below the reference, the high output above it, and the explanation that the huge open-loop gain saturates the output.
Eduqas 20226 marksExplain how positive feedback turns a comparator into a Schmitt trigger, and state why the resulting hysteresis is useful when the input is a slowly changing or noisy signal.Show worked answer →
Positive feedback and the Schmitt trigger (up to 4 marks): a fraction of the output is fed back to the non-inverting input. This makes the switching threshold depend on the current output state, so there are two thresholds: a higher one to switch one way and a lower one to switch back. When the output is low the upper threshold applies; when it is high the lower threshold applies. The gap between them is the hysteresis.
Why hysteresis helps (up to 2 marks): a plain comparator with a slowly changing or noisy input near its single threshold chatters, switching rapidly back and forth as noise crosses the threshold. The Schmitt trigger's two separated thresholds mean that once it switches, the input must move a definite amount back before it switches again, so noise no longer causes multiple unwanted transitions; the output is one clean edge.
Markers reward feedback to the non-inverting input, two thresholds with a hysteresis gap, and the clean, chatter-free switching of a noisy or slow input.
Related dot points
- Operational amplifiers: the ideal op-amp properties, the inverting, non-inverting, summing and difference amplifiers, the voltage follower, and the virtual earth.
An Eduqas A-Level Electronics answer on operational amplifiers: the ideal op-amp properties, the inverting and non-inverting amplifier gains, the summing and difference amplifiers, the voltage follower as a buffer, and the virtual-earth concept that makes the analysis simple.
- Instrumentation systems: sensors and transducers, the Wheatstone bridge, the instrumentation (difference) amplifier, common-mode rejection, and signal conditioning.
An Eduqas A-Level Electronics answer on instrumentation systems: input transducers and sensors, the Wheatstone bridge for small resistance changes, the instrumentation (difference) amplifier with high common-mode rejection, and the signal conditioning that turns a tiny noisy sensor signal into a clean usable voltage.
- Logic gates and Boolean algebra: the gates AND, OR, NOT, NAND, NOR, XOR and their truth tables, Boolean expressions, the laws of Boolean algebra, De Morgan's laws, and universal gates.
An Eduqas A-Level Electronics answer on logic gates and Boolean algebra: the gates AND, OR, NOT, NAND, NOR and XOR with their truth tables, writing and reading Boolean expressions, simplifying with the laws of Boolean algebra and De Morgan's laws, and the universal NAND and NOR gates.
- Timing circuits: the 555 timer in astable mode (frequency, period and duty cycle) and monostable mode (pulse duration), and oscillators for clock generation.
An Eduqas A-Level Electronics answer on timing circuits: the 555 timer in astable mode with its frequency, period and duty cycle, the monostable mode producing a single timed pulse, and the role of oscillators in generating a clock signal for digital systems.
Sources & how we know this
- Eduqas GCE AS/A Level Electronics specification (A410QS) — WJEC Eduqas (2017)