How do religious and ethical theories respond to beginning-of-life and end-of-life medical issues such as abortion and euthanasia?
Paper 2 Medical ethics: beginning and end of life issues: the sanctity and quality of life, personhood, abortion and embryo research, fertility treatment, euthanasia and assisted dying, analysed through natural moral law, situation ethics and utilitarianism.
An Edexcel A-Level Religious Studies Paper 2 guide to medical ethics at the beginning and end of life. Covers the sanctity and quality of life, personhood and autonomy, abortion, embryo research, fertility treatment, euthanasia and assisted dying, analysed through natural moral law (and double effect), situation ethics and utilitarianism, with the AO2 evaluation the exam rewards.
Reviewed by: AI editorial process; not yet individually human-reviewed
Have a quick question? Jump to the Q&A page
Jump to a section
What this dot point is asking
Edexcel Paper 2 closes with medical ethics: beginning and end of life issues. You apply the paper's ethical theories to real dilemmas at the start of life (abortion, embryo research, fertility treatment) and the end of life (euthanasia, assisted dying). The recurring tension is between the sanctity of life (life is intrinsically and equally valuable) and the quality of life and autonomy arguments (suffering and choice matter). The exam rewards applying a theory to a case and judging it, not narrating the medicine or the theory.
The answer
The sanctity versus quality of life
Most medical-ethics questions turn on which principle should dominate, and whether sanctity of life is an absolute or admits exceptions.
Beginning of life: abortion, embryo research, fertility
- Personhood. When does a human life with full moral status begin: at conception, viability, or birth? Natural law and Catholic teaching protect life from conception; others tie personhood to consciousness or viability.
- Abortion. The conflict is between the foetus's right to life and the mother's autonomy and circumstances (health, rape, foetal abnormality).
- Embryo research and fertility treatment. IVF, surrogacy and embryo research raise the status of the embryo, the permissibility of discarding embryos, and the means used to create life.
End of life: euthanasia and assisted dying
The three ethical theories applied
Examples in context
Try this
Q1. Evaluate the view that natural moral law gives the best approach to abortion. [20 marks]
- What the marker wants. An AO2 essay applying natural law (preservation of life, personhood from conception, double effect) to abortion, weighing its clarity and protection of the vulnerable against its rigidity over autonomy, hard cases and quality of life, with a justified conclusion.
Q2. Explain the difference between active and passive euthanasia. [8 marks]
- Cue. Active euthanasia is an act that directly causes death (e.g. a lethal injection); passive euthanasia is withholding or withdrawing treatment so the illness causes death. Add the voluntary/non-voluntary distinction and the moral weight placed on the acts/omissions difference for the higher marks.
Exam-style practice questions
Practice questions written in the style of Pearson Edexcel exam questions on this dot point, with worked answer explainers. The year tag is the paper they imitate, not the source.
Edexcel-style20 marksEvaluate the usefulness of situation ethics for resolving issues in medical ethics.Show worked answer →
A Section C extended essay marked mainly on AO2. The levels reward applying the theory to real medical cases and judging it, not describing the theory or the issue alone.
Apply. Situation ethics judges each case by agape: it would permit abortion or euthanasia where these are the most loving outcome (sparing suffering, respecting a mother's circumstances), making it flexible and person-centred rather than rule-bound.
Evaluate. Strengths: it responds to the particular case, weighs quality of life and autonomy, and avoids the rigidity of absolute rules. Weaknesses: love is hard to measure, it can justify almost anything, it offers patients and doctors little security, and predicting the most loving outcome is uncertain.
Compare with natural moral law's sanctity-of-life position and conclude with reasons. A clear verdict reaches the top level.
Edexcel-style20 marksAnalyse the view that the sanctity of life makes euthanasia always wrong.Show worked answer →
A Section C essay testing AO1 understanding of the sanctity-of-life principle and AO2 evaluation.
Explain. The sanctity-of-life principle holds that human life is intrinsically valuable because it is God-given and made in God's image, so it must not be deliberately taken; natural moral law's precept of preserving life and the doctrine of double effect (permitting pain relief that may shorten life, but not killing) follow from this.
Challenge. Quality-of-life and autonomy arguments hold that a life of unrelievable suffering may not be worth preserving and that competent patients have a right to choose; utilitarianism weighs the suffering prevented; situation ethics asks what love requires.
Judge whether sanctity of life is an absolute or admits exceptions, and conclude with reasons.
Related dot points
- Paper 2 A study of three ethical theories: natural moral law (Aquinas), situation ethics (Fletcher) and Aristotelian virtue ethics (Aristotle, Foot, MacIntyre), their key features, applications and criticisms.
An Edexcel A-Level Religious Studies Paper 2 guide to the three prescribed ethical theories. Covers natural moral law (Aquinas, the precepts and double effect), situation ethics (Fletcher, agape and the four working principles) and Aristotelian virtue ethics (eudaimonia, the golden mean, Foot and MacIntyre), with their applications and criticisms and the AO2 evaluation the exam rewards.
- Paper 2 Utilitarianism and deontology: Bentham's act and Mill's rule utilitarianism with later developments, and Kant's deontological ethics (the categorical imperative, duty and the good will), with applications and criticisms.
An Edexcel A-Level Religious Studies Paper 2 guide to utilitarianism and Kantian deontology. Covers Bentham's act utilitarianism and the hedonic calculus, Mill's rule and qualitative utilitarianism, preference and negative utilitarianism, and Kant's good will, duty and the three formulations of the categorical imperative, with applications and criticisms and the AO2 evaluation the exam rewards.
- Paper 2 The application of ethical theories and ethical language: applied ethics in war, sexual ethics and medical ethics, and meta-ethics including naturalism, intuitionism and emotivism.
An Edexcel A-Level Religious Studies Paper 2 guide to applied ethics and meta-ethics. Covers the application of ethical theories to war and peace, sexual ethics and medical ethics, and the meta-ethical debate over the meaning of moral language (ethical naturalism, Moore's intuitionism and the naturalistic fallacy, and Ayer's emotivism), with the AO2 evaluation the exam rewards.
- Paper 2 Significant concepts in issues or debates in religion and ethics: the relationship between religion and morality, divine command theory and the Euthyphro dilemma, the autonomy of ethics, and concepts such as duty, virtue, conscience and the good.
An Edexcel A-Level Religious Studies Paper 2 guide to significant concepts in moral debate and the relationship between religion and morality. Covers divine command theory and the Euthyphro dilemma, the autonomy of ethics (Kant, the secular challenge), whether morality depends on God, and key concepts such as duty, virtue, the good and conscience, with the AO2 evaluation the exam rewards.
- Paper 4B Significant social and historical developments and religion and society: secularisation, gender and feminist theology, science, religious pluralism, liberation theology and new theological movements.
An Edexcel A-Level Religious Studies Paper 4B (Christianity) guide to significant social developments and religion and society. Covers secularisation, gender and feminist theology (Daly, Ruether), the relationship with science, religious pluralism (exclusivism, inclusivism, pluralism), liberation theology and new movements (Pentecostalism), with the AO2 evaluation the exam rewards.
Sources & how we know this
- Pearson Edexcel A-Level Religious Studies (9RS0) specification — Pearson Edexcel (2016)
- Edexcel A-Level Religious Studies Anthology — Pearson Edexcel (2016)