How do the human relations school and theories of motivation explain what makes people work well?
The human relations school and motivation theories: Mayo's Hawthorne studies, Maslow's hierarchy of needs, Herzberg's two-factor theory and McGregor's Theory X and Theory Y, and what they imply for managing people.
How people are motivated in Advanced Higher Business Management: Mayo's human relations school, Maslow's hierarchy of needs, Herzberg's two-factor theory and McGregor's Theory X and Theory Y, and what each implies for managing staff.
Reviewed by: AI editorial process; not yet individually human-reviewed
Have a quick question? Jump to the Q&A page
Jump to a section
What this key area is asking
The human relations school grew out of the discovery that people are not machines: social and psychological needs drive their effort. Advanced Higher expects you to know Mayo's Hawthorne studies and the three classic theories of motivation, Maslow, Herzberg and McGregor, to describe each, compare them, and explain what they imply for managing people. The theme is that motivation goes far beyond money.
Mayo and the human relations school
Mayo found that productivity rose when workers were given attention and worked in cohesive groups, regardless of physical changes, the "Hawthorne effect". The lesson for managers: involve people, build good relationships and use teamwork, because feeling valued motivates.
Maslow's hierarchy of needs
- Physiological (pay for basics), then safety (job security, safe conditions), then social (belonging, teamwork), then esteem (recognition, status, promotion), then self-actualisation (achieving full potential, challenging work). The manager motivates by meeting needs in order.
Herzberg's two-factor theory
Frederick Herzberg split the factors affecting work into two distinct groups.
- Hygiene factors (pay, working conditions, job security, supervision, company policy): if poor, they cause dissatisfaction, but improving them only removes dissatisfaction, it does not motivate.
- Motivators (achievement, recognition, responsibility, the work itself, advancement): these positively motivate and come from the job's content.
The sharp implication: raising pay or improving conditions stops people being unhappy but will not motivate them; motivation comes from enriching the job with achievement and responsibility.
McGregor's Theory X and Theory Y
Douglas McGregor described two sets of managerial assumptions about workers.
- Theory X. People dislike work, avoid responsibility and must be controlled, directed and coerced, justifying tight supervision and a carrot-and-stick approach.
- Theory Y. People can enjoy work, seek responsibility and exercise self-direction, justifying trust, delegation and empowerment.
The assumption a manager holds shapes their style; a Theory Y approach often unlocks higher commitment, but the right assumption depends on the people and situation.
Examples in context
Why motivation theory matters
Motivation theory is the heart of managing people and links directly to leadership, teams and change: a leader's style, a team's cohesion and an organisation's ability to change all depend on whether staff are motivated. It is heavily examined and central to many project investigations into people and performance.
Try this
Q1. Distinguish between Herzberg's hygiene factors and motivators. [2 marks]
- Cue. Hygiene factors (pay, conditions, security) cause dissatisfaction if poor but do not motivate; motivators (achievement, recognition, responsibility) positively drive effort.
Q2. Explain how a Theory Y manager would treat staff differently from a Theory X manager. [4 marks]
- Cue. Theory X assumes people dislike work and need tight control and supervision; Theory Y assumes people seek responsibility, so the manager trusts, delegates and empowers, often gaining higher commitment.
Exam-style practice questions
Practice questions written in the style of SQA exam questions on this dot point, with worked answer explainers. The year tag is the paper they imitate, not the source.
SQA AH style8 marksCompare Maslow's and Herzberg's theories of motivation.Show worked answer →
Compare means draw out similarities and differences with a judgement. Both reject the classical idea that money is the only motivator and stress higher-level, psychological needs. Maslow proposes a hierarchy of five needs, physiological, safety, social, esteem and self-actualisation, satisfied in order, so a manager motivates by meeting the next unmet level. Herzberg splits factors into two: hygiene factors (pay, conditions, security, supervision) which cause dissatisfaction if poor but do not motivate, and motivators (achievement, recognition, responsibility, the work itself, advancement) which positively drive effort.
The key difference is that Maslow treats all needs as a single ascending ladder, while Herzberg separates the factors that prevent dissatisfaction from those that actually motivate, arguing that improving pay or conditions only removes dissatisfaction, not creates motivation. A strong answer pairs the points, both stress higher needs, but Maslow is a single hierarchy and Herzberg a two-factor split, and judges that Herzberg sharpens Maslow by warning that hygiene factors alone will not motivate.
SQA AH style6 marksExplain how an understanding of motivation theory could help a manager.Show worked answer →
Explain means reasons with development. Knowing Maslow, a manager can identify which level of need is unmet, for example providing job security (safety) or recognition and promotion (esteem), and target reward accordingly. Knowing Herzberg, a manager learns that fixing pay and conditions only stops dissatisfaction, so to motivate they must enrich jobs with achievement, responsibility and recognition. Knowing McGregor, a manager reflects on their own assumptions: a Theory X manager controls and supervises tightly, while a Theory Y manager who trusts and empowers staff often gets higher commitment. And Mayo shows that attention, teamwork and good relationships themselves raise motivation. The best answers turn each theory into a practical management action, not just a summary.
Related dot points
- Classical management theory: Taylor's scientific management (work study, the one best way, piece-rate pay) and Weber's bureaucracy (rules, hierarchy and impersonal authority), and their strengths and limitations.
The classical schools of management in Advanced Higher Business Management: Taylor's scientific management (work study, the one best way and piece-rate pay) and Weber's bureaucracy (rules, hierarchy and impersonal authority), with their strengths and limitations.
- The roles and functions of management: Fayol's functions of management (planning, organising, commanding, coordinating, controlling) and Mintzberg's managerial roles (interpersonal, informational and decisional), and how they describe managerial work.
What managers do in Advanced Higher Business Management: Fayol's five functions of management and Mintzberg's interpersonal, informational and decisional roles, and how the two frameworks together describe the reality of managerial work.
- Leadership theories: trait theory, behavioural/style theories (autocratic, democratic, laissez-faire) and situational theory (Hersey and Blanchard), and what they imply for how a leader should behave.
How leadership is explained in Advanced Higher Business Management: trait theory, behavioural style theories (autocratic, democratic and laissez-faire) and situational theory (Hersey and Blanchard), and what each implies for effective leadership.
- Teams and group working: the benefits and challenges of teamworking, Tuckman's stages of team development (forming, storming, norming, performing) and Belbin's team roles, and the features of an effective team.
How teams work in Advanced Higher Business Management: the benefits and challenges of teamworking, Tuckman's stages of team development and Belbin's team roles, and what makes a team effective.
- Workforce diversity and equality: the meaning of diversity, the requirements of the Equality Act (protected characteristics and avoiding discrimination), and the benefits and challenges of managing a diverse workforce.
How organisations manage diversity in Advanced Higher Business Management: what workforce diversity means, the Equality Act's protected characteristics and ban on discrimination, and the benefits and challenges of a diverse workforce.