Skip to main content
EnglandChemistrySyllabus dot point

What is the difference between metals and non-metals, and why do they form different ions?

Metals and non-metals; their positions in the periodic table; the ions they form; the link between electronic structure and reactivity.

A focused answer to AQA GCSE Chemistry 4.1.2, covering where metals and non-metals sit in the periodic table, the ions they form, and how electronic structure explains why metals lose electrons and non-metals gain them.

Generated by Claude Opus 4.88 min answer

Reviewed by: AI editorial process; not yet individually human-reviewed

Have a quick question? Jump to the Q&A page

Jump to a section
  1. What this dot point is asking
  2. Where they sit
  3. The ions they form
  4. Linking to reactivity
  5. Why metals lose and non-metals gain
  6. Try this

What this dot point is asking

AQA wants you to explain where metals and non-metals sit in the periodic table, describe the typical properties of each, state the type of ions they form, and use electronic structure to explain why metals tend to lose electrons and non-metals tend to gain electrons. The unifying idea is that atoms react to reach a full, stable outer shell, and whether they lose or gain depends on how many outer electrons they start with.

Where they sit

Most elements are metals, on the left and centre of the table. Non-metals are on the right-hand side, including the noble gases in Group 0. The boundary runs roughly diagonally down the right side. Metals are typically shiny, good conductors of heat and electricity, malleable and have high melting points; non-metals are typically dull, poor conductors and often have low melting points.

The ions they form

When metals react, they lose their outer electrons to become positive ions. For example, sodium (2,8,12,8,1) loses one electron to form Na+Na^+ (2,82,8), and magnesium (2,8,22,8,2) loses two to form Mg2+Mg^{2+}. Non-metals gain electrons to fill their outer shell, for example chlorine (2,8,72,8,7) gains one to form Clβˆ’Cl^- (2,8,82,8,8), and oxygen (2,62,6) gains two to form O2βˆ’O^{2-}.

The charge on the ion equals the number of electrons lost (positive) or gained (negative), which is why Group 1 forms +1+1 ions, Group 2 forms +2+2, Group 6 forms βˆ’2-2 and Group 7 forms βˆ’1-1.

Linking to reactivity

The number of outer electrons decides how an element reacts. Group 1 metals (one outer electron) lose it readily and are reactive; Group 7 non-metals (seven outer electrons) gain one readily and are reactive. The noble gases already have full outer shells, so they are unreactive and do not normally form ions.

Why metals lose and non-metals gain

The reason comes down to how many electrons each atom must move to reach a full shell. A metal has only a few outer electrons, so the easiest route to a full outer shell is to lose those few; a non-metal has nearly a full outer shell, so the easiest route is to gain the small number of electrons it is missing. Losing electrons leaves the metal ion with more protons than electrons, hence a positive charge; gaining electrons gives the non-metal ion more electrons than protons, hence a negative charge. This is why metals and non-metals always form oppositely charged ions, which then attract to form ionic compounds. The size of the charge follows the same logic: a Group 2 metal loses two electrons to form a 2+2+ ion, and a Group 6 non-metal gains two to form a 2βˆ’2- ion.

Try this

Q1. State the type of ion a metal forms and explain why. [2 marks]

  • Cue. A positive ion, because it loses its outer electrons.

Q2. Write the ion formed by oxygen (2,62,6) and explain how it forms. [2 marks]

  • Cue. O2βˆ’O^{2-}, formed by gaining two electrons to complete its outer shell.

Q3. Write the ion formed by potassium (2,8,8,12,8,8,1). [1 mark]

  • Cue. K+K^+, formed by losing its single outer electron.

Exam-style practice questions

Practice questions written in the style of AQA exam questions on this dot point, with worked answer explainers. The year tag is the paper they imitate, not the source.

AQA 20194 marksSodium is a metal in Group 1 and chlorine is a non-metal in Group 7. Using their electronic structures, explain the type of ion each forms when they react together, and write the formula of each ion.
Show worked answer β†’

A 4-mark question on ion formation from electronic structure.

Sodium (2,8,12,8,1) has one outer electron; as a metal it loses this electron to gain a full outer shell, forming a positive ion Na+Na^+ (22 marks: loses one electron, forms Na+Na^+). Chlorine (2,8,72,8,7) has seven outer electrons; as a non-metal it gains one electron to fill its outer shell, forming a negative ion Clβˆ’Cl^- (22 marks: gains one electron, forms Clβˆ’Cl^-).

Markers reward linking the number of outer electrons to losing or gaining, and correct ion charges and signs.

AQA 20213 marksExplain, in terms of electronic structure, why metals form positive ions but non-metals form negative ions when they react. State what stable arrangement both are reaching towards.
Show worked answer β†’

A 3-mark question on the reason behind ion formation.

Metals (1 mark): they have few electrons in their outer shell, so it is easier to lose them than to gain a full shell; losing electrons leaves more protons than electrons, giving a positive ion. Non-metals (1 mark): they have nearly full outer shells, so it is easier to gain a few electrons to fill the shell; gaining electrons gives more electrons than protons, a negative ion. Stable arrangement (1 mark): both are reaching a full outer shell, like the nearest noble gas.

Markers want the few-versus-nearly-full reasoning and the noble-gas stability point.

Related dot points

Sources & how we know this