How do we identify ions and gases by their characteristic reactions?
Tests for cations and anions including carbonate, sulfate, halide, ammonium and hydroxide, tests for common gases, flame tests, and the chemistry behind each observation.
A CCEA A-Level Chemistry answer on qualitative analysis, covering the tests for carbonate, sulfate, halide, ammonium and hydroxide ions, the tests for common gases, flame tests, and the observations and chemistry behind each identification.
Reviewed by: AI editorial process; not yet individually human-reviewed
Have a quick question? Jump to the Q&A page
Jump to a section
What this dot point is asking
CCEA wants you to carry out and interpret tests for common cations and anions, including carbonate, sulfate, halide, ammonium and hydroxide ions, tests for common gases, and flame tests, explaining the observations and the chemistry behind each.
Tests for anions
The nitric acid removes carbonate or hydroxide ions that would otherwise give a false precipitate. The chemistry behind each test is worth knowing as an ionic equation: the carbonate test is ; the sulfate test is (white); and the halide test is (and similarly for bromide and iodide). The silver halides are then distinguished by their solubility in ammonia: silver chloride dissolves in dilute ammonia, silver bromide dissolves only in concentrated ammonia, and silver iodide stays insoluble even in concentrated ammonia. This ammonia step mirrors the trend that the silver halides become less soluble down Group VII.
Tests for cations
The ammonium test works because the hydroxide ion is a strong enough base to displace ammonia from the ammonium ion: . The ammonia is detected by its smell and by turning damp red litmus blue. The metal hydroxide precipitates form because most metal hydroxides are insoluble: iron(II) gives a green precipitate that slowly turns brown as it is oxidised in air, iron(III) gives a red-brown precipitate, and copper(II) gives a pale blue precipitate. The colour of the precipitate, together with whether it redissolves in excess sodium hydroxide, narrows down the cation.
Tests for gases
- Oxygen: relights a glowing splint.
- Hydrogen: burns with a squeaky pop using a lighted splint.
- Carbon dioxide: turns limewater milky.
- Ammonia: turns damp red litmus blue and has a pungent smell.
- Chlorine: bleaches damp blue litmus paper.
Flame tests
Examples in context
Example 1. Firework colours. The colours in a firework are flame tests on a large scale: strontium and lithium salts give red, sodium salts give yellow, barium salts give green, and copper salts give blue-green. The metal ions are excited by the heat of the burning fuel and emit light of characteristic wavelengths as their electrons fall back. CCEA expects candidates to explain firework colours with the same electron-excitation reasoning used for the laboratory flame test.
Example 2. Detecting hard water and sulfate pollution. Water companies use the acidified barium chloride test to measure sulfate levels in drinking water and in industrial discharge, because barium sulfate's insolubility makes the white precipitate a sensitive indicator. The same insoluble barium sulfate, formed in the laboratory test, links directly to the Group II trend that sulfate solubility falls down the group. This shows how a simple qualitative test underpins real environmental monitoring.
Try this
Q1. Describe the test for a sulfate ion and the positive result. [2 marks]
- Cue. Add acidified barium chloride; a white precipitate of barium sulfate forms.
Q2. State the flame colour for potassium. [1 mark]
- Cue. Lilac.
Exam-style practice questions
Practice questions written in the style of CCEA exam questions on this dot point, with worked answer explainers. The year tag is the paper they imitate, not the source.
CCEA 20206 marksAn unknown white solid is thought to be either sodium carbonate or sodium sulfate. Describe the tests you would carry out to identify which it is, giving the reagents, the observations, and an ionic equation for each positive result.Show worked answer β
Markers want a test for each anion, the observations, and ionic equations.
Test for carbonate: add dilute hydrochloric (or nitric) acid to a sample. If carbonate is present, there is effervescence and the gas turns limewater milky:
.
Sulfate gives no reaction with the acid.
Test for sulfate: to a fresh sample, add dilute nitric acid (or hydrochloric acid) then aqueous barium chloride. If sulfate is present, a white precipitate of barium sulfate forms:
.
Carbonate would also give a white precipitate with barium chloride, which is why the sample is acidified first: the acid removes any carbonate as carbon dioxide so only sulfate gives the precipitate.
Markers reward the acid test with effervescence and limewater for carbonate, the acidified barium chloride test for sulfate, both ionic equations, and the reason for acidifying.
CCEA 20184 marksDescribe how a flame test is carried out and state the flame colours you would expect for sodium, potassium and calcium. Explain in outline why the colours are produced.Show worked answer β
A method-plus-explanation question.
Method: clean a nichrome (or platinum) wire by dipping it in concentrated hydrochloric acid and holding it in a hot blue Bunsen flame until there is no colour. Dip the clean wire into the solid (moistened with a little concentrated hydrochloric acid) and hold it at the edge of a blue flame.
Colours: sodium gives a yellow (golden) flame, potassium gives a lilac (pale purple) flame, and calcium gives a brick-red flame.
Explanation: the heat of the flame excites the outer electrons to higher energy levels. When these electrons fall back to lower levels they emit energy as light of a definite wavelength (colour), and the energy gaps, and so the colour, are characteristic of each metal ion.
Markers reward the cleaning step, the three correct colours, and the explanation in terms of electrons being excited and emitting light as they fall back.
Related dot points
- Trends in reactivity, melting point, solubility and thermal stability down Group II, the reactions of Group II metals and compounds, the trends in Group VII including colour, volatility and oxidising power, displacement reactions and tests for halide ions.
A CCEA A-Level Chemistry answer on Group II and Group VII, covering the trends in reactivity and solubility down Group II and the reactions of its compounds, and the trends in colour, volatility and oxidising power down Group VII, halogen displacement reactions and the tests for halide ions.
- Periodicity of atomic radius, ionisation energy and melting point across Period 3, the structures and bonding of the Period 3 elements and oxides, and the trends in the acid-base character of the oxides.
A CCEA A-Level Chemistry answer on periodicity, covering the trends in atomic radius, ionisation energy and melting point across Period 3, the structures and bonding of the Period 3 elements, and the trend from basic to acidic character in the Period 3 oxides.
- Oxidation and reduction in terms of electron transfer, oxidation numbers and the rules for assigning them, identifying oxidising and reducing agents, and constructing and combining half-equations into balanced redox equations.
A CCEA A-Level Chemistry answer on redox chemistry, covering oxidation and reduction as electron transfer, the rules for assigning oxidation numbers, identifying oxidising and reducing agents, and constructing and combining half-equations into balanced overall redox equations.
- The mole and the Avogadro constant, molar mass, empirical and molecular formulae, the ideal gas equation, concentrations of solutions, and reacting mass, gas volume and titration calculations including percentage yield and atom economy.
A CCEA A-Level Chemistry answer on the mole and the Avogadro constant, molar mass, empirical and molecular formulae, the ideal gas equation, solution concentrations, and reacting mass, gas volume and titration calculations including percentage yield and atom economy.
- Ionic, covalent, dative covalent and metallic bonding, electronegativity and bond polarity, electron-pair repulsion and the shapes of simple molecules and ions, and the link between structure and physical properties.
A CCEA A-Level Chemistry answer on ionic, covalent, dative covalent and metallic bonding, electronegativity and bond polarity, electron-pair repulsion theory and the shapes of simple molecules and ions, and how structure determines physical properties.
Sources & how we know this
- CCEA GCE Chemistry specification β CCEA (2016)