Why did Gorbachev's reforms fail to save the Soviet Union and instead hasten its collapse in 1991?
The end of the USSR 1985 to 1991: Gorbachev's perestroika and glasnost, the loosening of the bloc and nationalism, the 1991 coup, and the collapse of the Soviet Union.
A focused guide to Gorbachev and the collapse of the Soviet Union for AQA A-Level History (Russia). Covers perestroika and glasnost, the loosening of the Eastern bloc and rising nationalism, the August 1991 coup, and the dissolution of the USSR.
Reviewed by: AI editorial process; not yet individually human-reviewed
Have a quick question? Jump to the Q&A page
Jump to a section
What this dot point is asking
You need to explain why Gorbachev's reforms (perestroika and glasnost) failed to save the Soviet Union, how the Eastern bloc and Soviet republics broke away, and how the August 1991 coup led to the collapse of the USSR.
Perestroika and glasnost
In practice the two policies pulled against each other. Glasnost released a flood of criticism that, once started, could not be limited: revelations about Stalin's crimes, Chernobyl (1986) and the war in Afghanistan discredited the party, while newly free expression gave nationalist movements in the Baltic states, the Caucasus and Ukraine a voice and a platform. Perestroika half-dismantled the command economy (the 1987 Law on State Enterprises, the legalisation of small cooperatives) without building working markets, so the old system of plan targets broke down before anything replaced it, and shortages worsened. Gorbachev had loosened control faster than he could manage the consequences.
The loosening of the bloc
Nationalism and Yeltsin
Within the USSR, nationalism surged: the Baltic republics (Lithuania declared independence in 1990), the Caucasus and others demanded to leave the union, and Gorbachev's attempts to negotiate a looser Union Treaty satisfied no one. Crucially, in Russia itself, Boris Yeltsin emerged as a rival pole of power. Having broken with Gorbachev, he was elected President of the Russian Republic in June 1991, championing radical reform and Russian sovereignty against the union centre, so that the largest republic now pulled away from the very state Gorbachev led.
The 1991 coup and collapse
In August 1991 hardline Communists, fearing the new Union Treaty would dissolve the USSR, staged a coup, placing Gorbachev under house arrest in the Crimea. It collapsed within three days: the plotters were irresolute, the army would not fire on civilians, and Yeltsin climbed onto a tank outside the Russian parliament to rally defiance, becoming the hero of the hour. The coup destroyed what authority Gorbachev and the Communist Party had left. Over the following months the republics declared independence one after another; in December the leaders of Russia, Ukraine and Belarus dissolved the union and formed the Commonwealth of Independent States. The Soviet Union was formally dissolved at the end of 1991, and Gorbachev resigned on 25 December.
Try this
Q1. What did glasnost mean? [2 marks]
- Cue. "Openness": relaxing censorship and allowing public criticism and debate.
Q2. What was the significance of the August 1991 coup? [2 marks]
- Cue. Its failure discredited the hardliners and Gorbachev and hastened the dissolution of the USSR.
Exam-style practice questions
Practice questions written in the style of AQA exam questions on this dot point, with worked answer explainers. The year tag is the paper they imitate, not the source.
AQA 202020 marks'Gorbachev's own reforms were the main reason for the collapse of the USSR in the years 1985 to 1991.' Assess the validity of this view. (Component 2, depth essay, rescoped from 25)Show worked answer →
Weigh Gorbachev's reforms against the deeper inherited problems and rank them.
Argue for the claim: glasnost unleashed criticism and nationalism the system could not contain; perestroika disrupted the planned economy without building a working market; and abandoning the Brezhnev Doctrine let the Eastern bloc fall in 1989, fatally weakening the centre.
Weigh the other factors: decades of Brezhnev-era stagnation, the unaffordable arms race with the United States, deep-rooted ethnic nationalism in the republics, and the rise of Yeltsin as a rival pole of power in Russia.
Reach a judgement. Markers reward ranking, for example that the reforms were the trigger but acted on a system already failing, so they accelerated rather than caused the collapse. A top level answer sustains that argument.
AQA 20226 marksWith reference to a Western newspaper report on the August 1991 coup and your own knowledge, assess its value for studying the fall of Gorbachev. (Component 2, source skill)Show worked answer →
A short source question rewards judging value through provenance, content and context.
Provenance: a Western newspaper writes from outside the USSR, with access to its own reporting but a Cold War-era interpretive lens, so it gives immediacy and an outsider's analysis but may misread internal Soviet dynamics.
Content and tone: weigh its account of the coup, Yeltsin's defiance on the tank, and Gorbachev's isolation against your knowledge of why the coup failed.
Judgement: a historian could reliably learn how events were understood at the time and the symbolism of Yeltsin's stand, but must cross-check detail and watch for Western framing. Markers reward a clear value judgement set against context.
Related dot points
- The USSR 1953 to 1982: de-Stalinisation and Khrushchev's reforms and failures, the Brezhnev era of stability and stagnation, and Soviet society and the Cold War context.
A focused guide to the USSR under Khrushchev and Brezhnev for AQA A-Level History (Russia). Covers de-Stalinisation and Khrushchev's reforms and failures, the Brezhnev era of stability and stagnation, and Soviet society and the Cold War context.
- Stalin's rule 1924 to 1953: the rise to power, collectivisation and the Five Year Plans, the Great Terror and the cult of personality, and the impact of the Second World War.
A focused guide to Stalin and the USSR from 1924 to 1953 for AQA A-Level History (Russia). Covers his rise to power, collectivisation and the Five Year Plans, the Great Terror and the cult of personality, and the impact of the Second World War.
- Lenin in power 1917 to 1924: consolidating the one-party state, winning the Civil War, War Communism and its failures, and the introduction of the New Economic Policy.
A focused guide to Lenin in power and the Russian Civil War for AQA A-Level History (Russia). Covers the consolidation of the one-party state, the Civil War and Red victory, War Communism and its failures, and the introduction of the New Economic Policy.
- The revolutions of 1917: the fall of the Tsar in February, the failures of the Provisional Government and dual power, and the Bolshevik seizure of power in October.
A focused guide to the Russian revolutions of 1917 for AQA A-Level History (Russia, Tsarism to Communism). Covers the fall of the Tsar in February, the failures of the Provisional Government and dual power, and the Bolshevik seizure of power in October.
- The NEA: choosing a viable question over roughly 100 years and distinct from the exam options, evaluating primary sources and interpretations, and reaching a supported judgement within the word limit.
How to plan the AQA A-Level History Historical Investigation (NEA, Component 3). Covers choosing a viable question covering roughly 100 years and distinct from your exam options, evaluating primary sources and historians' interpretations, and reaching a supported judgement within the word limit.
Sources & how we know this
- AQA A-level History (7042) specification — AQA (2015)